Which method of classroom management was effectively used in the situation with Tony?

Shared control through a menu project is a method that promotes student agency and ownership in the learning process, which is particularly effective in classroom management. This approach allows students, like Tony, to make choices about their assignments or projects from a selection, fostering engagement and motivation. By giving students a voice in how they learn or demonstrate their knowledge, teachers can create a more positive classroom environment where students feel respected and valued.

This method encourages collaboration and communication between the teacher and students, which helps to reduce disruptive behaviors and enhances overall classroom dynamics. When students feel in control of their learning, they are more likely to take responsibility for their actions and work independently, leading to a more harmonious classroom.

In contrast, zero tolerance policies can create a punitive environment that may not address the underlying issues of student behavior. Rigid grading standards might discourage creativity and lead to anxiety among students, impairing their willingness to participate. Individual tutoring sessions, while beneficial for specific academic support, do not provide the same level of collaborative engagement and choice that a menu project offers.